Thursday 26 September 2013

ACCG's Tompa: Due Diligence "Objectionable"


Collectors say that they want to help preserve the past. Collectors say they deplore looting and would "never" knowingly buy a stolen or looted object. Dealer say the same things.  There is however a huge gap  between insincere declarative posturing and action. ACCG's Peter Tompa (lobbyist for numismatic trade associations) discusses the "Red List of Syrian Cultural Objects at Risk" (noting sourly that it was produced "with the support of the State Department's Cultural Heritage Center"). He takes exception to this bit of the all-too-brief document:
"Museums, auction houses, art dealers and collectors are encouraged not to acquire such objects [ie originating from Syria] without having carefully and thoroughly researched their origin and all the relevant legal documentation."
Mr Tompa labels this "objectionable" and says it "makes little sense" in today's antiquity market ("the objects on the list are presumed "guilty" until proven "innocent"..." and it breaks their little hearts).  

Mr Tompa calls my opinions "surreal", but I say  "Museums, auction houses, art dealers and collectors should be encouraged not to acquire ANY dugup ancient objects without having carefully and thoroughly researched their origin and all the relevant legal documentation". What is actually surreal about that? It's what we call due diligence, and its what all collectors and dealers (declaratively) claim indignantly they are all already doing.


2 comments:

Cultural Property Observer said...

But your friend David Knell makes the same complaint with regard to his interest, oil lamps in comments to another post.

Is this about really preserving Syria's cultural heritage or furthering an anti-collector agenda?

Paul Barford said...

Where does David Knell "make the same complaint with regard to his interest, oil lamps in comments to another post"? Link please. Can't recall him saying that.

"Is this about really preserving Syria's cultural heritage or furthering an anti-collector agenda? " You are beginning to sound like Dave Welsh. Now THAT is "surreal".

Can you tell me, if there were no collectors to buy this stuff, how much money would the middlemen make from the old pots and dirty chunks of stone?

 
Creative Commons License
Ten utwór jest dostępny na licencji Creative Commons Uznanie autorstwa-Bez utworów zależnych 3.0 Unported.